Dr. Shirley walks out of his last tour performance due to the location refusing to serve him and plays in a black restaurant down the street.
They get back to New York in time for Frank to have Christmas Eve with his family and Dr. Shirley joins them.
Frank Vallelonga (Viggo Mortensen) is a bouncer at the Copa Cabana who’s unemployed for 8 weeks while the club gets renovated. Even though he’s seen throwing out glasses after his wife, Dolores serves two black repair men lemonade, he agrees to drive Dr. Don Shirley (Mahershala Ali) on an eight week concert tour to the deep south and keep him out of trouble. The record company provides him a copy of the Negro Motorist’s Green Book, a guide to what southern establishments will serve black guests and tells him that if Dr. Shirley does not make all his performances, Frank will not receive half of his pay.
Over the course of the trip, Frank teaches Don about things like pop music and fried chicken, all things he’s avoided. Don assists Frank with writing letters home to his wife to the delight of her and his family. Frank also rescues Don from angry white bar patrons who beat him and bribes 2 police officers into releasing Don after he’s caught having a homosexual encounter at a YMCA. Don uses his connection to Robert Kennedy to get them both released from jail after Frank punches a cop who pulls them over in a sunset town, a town where blacks are not allowed inside city limits at night.
Frank watches Don be treated poorly throughout the trip; staying in worse hotels than the him, being refused food, being told he can’t use the bathroom at venues he’s playing and questions why, particularly when told that he would make more money playing up north but finds out that he’s doing it in an attempt to change opinions of blacks in the south. At the last establishment Don is giving a closet as a changing room at a large venue where he is the guest of honor and told that they will not serve him dinner at the restaurant. Tired of the treatment, he announces that he will not play the sold out Christmas concert unless they serve him at the restaurant. When they refuse he leaves and goes to a black restaurant up the road where he eats dinner with Frank and then plays the piano for the patrons there.
Don then suggests they leave immediately for New York so Frank can spend Christmas Eve with his family but get caught in a snow storm. As Frank gets too tired to drive and decides to give up, we see Don complete the drive to Frank’s house, sending him upstairs to his family despite an invitation to join them. Frank corrects his family not to use derogatory terms (Italian for eggplant) to describe Dr. Shirley. Dr. Shirley goes home to his apartment then decides to visit Frank’s family after all where he’s greeted warmly and thanked by Dolores who whispers that she’s glad he helped Frank write her. The ending credits show pictures of the real life Don Shirley, Frank and Dolores and explain that Frank went back to the Copa Cobana after the trip.
In 1962 in New York City, Tony “Tony Lip” Vallelonga (Viggo Mortensen) is a doorman and peacekeeper at the Copacabana nightclub. He’s known as Tony Lip because he’s an amazing bullshitter – getting people to do what they don’t want to. He does what he has to to put food on his family’s table. When two men start getting into a fist fight, he tosses one out onto the street and gives him a few punches in the face when he resists. He pays the coat check girl to take a rich patron’s prized hat so he can “find” it and return it to him for a very big tip.
The club closes for a few months for renovations, leaving Tony out of work. He and his wife, Dolores (Linda Cardellini), are having trouble making the rent and keeping a roof over their two kids’ home. When two black men come over to repair the sink, Dolores gives them lemonade – and Tony throws out their glasses after they use them, much to Dolores’s disappointment. Tony makes fifty bucks in a hot dog eating contest to make ends meet. An old contact gets him an interview to be a driver for a doctor, and he goes to Carnegie Hall for the interview. He mistakenly goes to the venue, but learns there’s an apartment upstairs. It’s ornate and filled with objects around the world. Dr. Don Shirley (Mahershala Ali). He’s not a medical doctor, but a concert pianist. He’s doing a concert tour going from the Midwest into the deep south, and needs a driver, but he asked around specifically for someone who could handle trouble – he knows there’s going to be racism against him. The tour is two months long, and ends right before Christmas. He asks Tony if he can be away from his family that long, and Tony agrees for the right money. But when Dr. Shirley insists that Tony be prepared to iron his clothes and shine his shoes, Tony refuses, saying he’s not a butler. Dr. Shirley dismisses him.
Tony goes to a bar, upset he fumbled the interview, and a couple of mobsters he knows from the club offer him unsavory work. He declines, lying that he’s got money saved. Early the next morning, Dr. Shirley calls Tony’s house and asks to speak to Dolores. He asks her if she’s okay with her husband being gone for so long. When she agrees, he offers Tony the job. Dolores asks Tony to write her letters, much to his chagrin. The record company rents Tony a nice car, and gives him half the money up front, and tells him he’ll get half at the end of the tour – if Dr. Shirley misses a show, he won’t get the money. They also give him the ‘Green Book’, a tourist guide and list of safe places for black people to stay in the south.
Tony is a loudmouth and a talker, and gets on Dr. Shirley’s nerves a lot during the drive. As they approach their first tour stop, Dr. Shirley suggests that Tony use a different last name and try to talk better around the guests, but Tony says if they have a problem with how he talks, he’ll wait outside, which he does. From outside he watches Dr. Shirley play piano and is impressed with how brilliant he is. Afterwards, he gambles with the other help who are all also outside, and Dr. Shirley is upset with him for being so low-class. Tony wants to know why Dr. Shirley is giving him such a hard time and no one else – and Dr. Shirley says it’s because unlike the other help, Tony had the option of being inside.
In the car, Tony plays contemporary music on the radio and is shocked when Dr. Shirley doesn’t know popular music like Aretha Franklin. He questions if Dr. Shirley is even black, and when he drives by a Kentucky Fried Chicken and finds out Dr. Shirley has never had fried chicken, he stops. He playfully forces Dr. Shirley to try the chicken. Tony works on his letters for Dolores, and they’re terrible, so Dr. Shirley helps him make them more poetic and beautiful. At a later stop, Tony finds a gemstone that’s being sold on the ground and pockets it, but Dr. Shirley forces him to put it back, saying it’s stealing even though Tony disagrees.
As they enter the south, Dr. Shirley has to stay at blacks only hotels separate from Tony. Alone, Dr. Shirley drinks by himself, alienated from the other people at the hotel. Tony gets a call at his room that there’s a skirmish happening at a local bar, where he finds Dr. Shirley being assaulted by white patrons. Tony reaches for a gun and claims he’ll shoot if they don’t let him go. They narrowly escape, and Dr. Shirley asks if he really has a gun. Tony says of course not, and orders Dr. Shirley to go nowhere without him.
At the next concert venue at a Southern mansion, the host is very friendly to Dr. Shirley. For dinner he has had the cooks prepared fried chicken. At intermission, Dr. Shirley asks to use the bathroom, and the host directs him to the outhouse, not allowing him to use the inside bathroom. Dr. Shirley refuses to use the outhouse, so Tony drives him back to his hotel just to use the bathroom there.
At the next stop, the two walk by a suit store, and when Dr. Shirley admires a suit in the window, Joe insists he buy it. When they enter the store, the employees refuse to sell Dr. Shirley a suit. That evening, Tony is called to a disturbance at a local YMCA where Dr. Shirley and another man have been arrested – apparently the gym manager caught them messing around. Tony bribes the police officers to let Dr. Shirley go.
At the next town, Tony runs into the mobsters. In Italian, in front of Dr. Shirley, they tell Tony that he should quit and come work for them. Tony agrees to meet them for a drink later that night. As they check into their hotel, Dr. Shirley offers Tony a raise and a promotion. Tony refuses to accept, and Dr. Shirley reveals he speaks Italian. Tony explains he was never going to take the job, he was going to meet them and tell them now. Dr. Shirley is relieved. He awkwardly apologizes to Tony for the situation the night before, but Tony explains that he’s been working in New York City nightclubs for years and knows that the world is “complicated”.
Dr. Shirley continues to help Tony with the letters, which continue to impress Dolores and the rest of his family. On the way to their final stop, they are pulled over by the police. The officer tells them that Dr. Shirley can’t be out past sundown. They are both forced out of the car, and the officer asks Tony for his ID. When he asks Tony what kind of name Vallelonga is, Tony says Italian – and the officer says he’s “half a n—-r”. Tony immediately punches him in the face, and both are taken to jail. Dr. Shirley is enraged at Tony, since his hot head cost them the tour. He demands to make a phone call, since he committed no crime. He does, and the police receive an angry call from the Governor and reluctantly release them. Dr. Shirley reveals to Tony that he called Bobby Kennedy. Tony thinks that’s amazing, but Dr. Shirley is furious. He is embarrassed that someone so important now sees him as a rabble-rouser. The two men have a huge fight over all their differences – Dr. Shirley sees a man who refuses to better himself, and Tony sees a man who seems to make things more difficult for himself and fits in nowhere. Dr. Shirley screams at Tony, “if I’m not black enough, and I’m not white enough, I’m not man enough, then what am I?”
The two arrive at the final concert venue, where Dr. Shirley is shown to a tiny closet that they refer to as his dressing room. Tony goes to eat in the dining room with the players in the band, but when Dr. Shirley arrives to join them, the concierge refuses to let him eat there. Dr. Shirley refuses to play unless he is able to eat in the dining room. The concierge won’t allow it, and Tony pulls him aside to talk to him. Tony tries to reason with him, but the concierge tries to bribe him to get Dr. Shirley to play. Dr. Shirley enters, and tells Tony he’ll do the show if Tony wants, knowing Tony won’t get paid unless they finish the tour. But Tony sticks with Dr. Shirley, and they bail on the gig despite the screams of the concierge.
They go down the street to a bar for black people. Dr. Shirley buys a round of drinks, flashing his wallet filled with money, which a couple youths see. After some prodding, Dr. Shirley plays piano with the jazz band. When they leave, Tony spots the two youths waiting behind their car to mug them, and fires two shots off into the air, revealing he did have a gun all along.
Tony and Dr. Shirley begin their drive back to New York, hoping to make it by Christmas Eve. The weather is really bad, with a lot of snow. They get pulled over again, but this time the cop just warns them their tire is skidding. Tony can’t stay awake any longer and can barely see through the snow, and accepts he won’t make it home and goes to sleep – but while he sleeps Dr. Shirley drives them the rest of the way to Tony’s apartment. He wakes Tony up and encourages him to go home – Tony invites him but he declines. Tony goes upstairs and surprises his family. Dr. Shirley returns to his ornate apartment, and sits there alone. He ends up coming to Tony’s, and while most of his family is a little confused, Dolores joyously welcomes him and thanks him for helping Tony with his letters.
The post-script reveals that in real life, Tony became the maitre’D of the Copa, and Dr. Shirley continued being successful in music. They remained friends for the rest of their lives.